Craig Steiner, u.s. Common Sense American Conservatism |
About Me & This Website My Positions On Facebook Contact Me Articles |
Republicans and Democrats have been trying to reach an agreement on how to reduce the deficit as a prerequisite for raising the debt ceiling. Last week it was announced that President Obama would become involved to try to break the logjam. I joked, on Facebook: "Obama's getting involved? Debt crisis for sure. I'm only somewhat kidding. After all, has Obama ever entered a partisan dispute and actually made things better?" I shouldn't have joked. Republicans have proposed cutting spending. Democrats have suggested increasing spending and raising taxes. As a bipartisan compromise, Obama has suggested increasing spending and raising taxes. In all seriousness, that's apparently Obama's idea of compromise. And that means trimming the defense budget, while still meeting our security needs. It means we'll have to tackle entitlements, as long as we keep faith with seniors and children with disabilities by maintaining the fundamental security that Medicare and Medicaid provide. And, yes, we're going to have to tackle spending in the tax code. In other words, he's suggesting we're all going to have to sacrifice--but without pain. In his vision, the only pain will be burdened by the wealthy. But that's not reality and we all know it. There's going to be sacrifice, and it's not just going to be on the part of the wealthy. The out-of-control spending has guaranteed that everyone--including the middle class and below--will be participating in the pain and sacrifice. To say otherwise is dishonest. And please, Mr. President, please stop insulting us with "spending in the tax code." Everyone knows that means "tax hikes" and you insult our intelligence--and make a mockery of yourself--every time you repeat that nonsense phrase that just makes people laugh. Time to Get serious - Taxes Aren't Going Up Raising taxes is a non-starter for several reasons:
We Don't Need to Raise Taxes Claims by Democrats that we need to raise taxes (on the wealthy or anyone else) are without merit. It's not like we lowered taxes last year and our deficit spiked. We lowered tax rates a decade ago. From the time tax rates were cut until the recession, federal revenue went up every year but one--even with the lower tax rates. Even though taxes were cut in 2001, revenue increased $530 billion from FY2001 to FY2008. The problem is that spending increased over twice as much by $1,120 billion. So the problem isn't too little taxes. The problem is too much spending. Our deficit isn't caused by tax breaks for the wealthy. The problem is that government spending is just completely out of control. It's offensive to suggest that anyone--wealthy or not--should be asked to sacrifice for such a wasteful and proliferate government that can't live within its means. Cutting Spending Should be Bipartisan For decades, increasing spending and the size of government has been a bipartisan endeavor. Republicans and Democrats in the presidency, U.S. House, and U.S. Senate have all done it. No-one is innocent of increasing spending and increasing the size of government. The difference is that now Republicans have realized that it's necessary to make difficult and unpopular decisions in regards to cutting spending. Republicans have had the guts to present ideas and budgets that touch programs that are politically dangerous. Republicans are not proposing tough medicine out of some self-abusive desire to provoke electoral anger at themselves leading into a presidential election. They're not doing it because they want to open themselves to petty political attacks by Democrats. Republicans are doing it because it's necessary. Someone has to be the adults in the room to actually lead and make tough decisions. And it's painfully obvious that neither President Obama nor Democrats in Congress are going to do it. Democrats are closing their eyes and pretending that politics as usual will get the job done. It won't. They're focused on typical election-cycle posturing while Republicans are offering substantive solutions to actually address our problems. Democrats are engaging in the same kind of class warfare nonsense that sometimes succeeds at getting them elected, but which has no chance of fixing our precarious fiscal situation. Obama and Democrats are drawing a line in the sand--demanding tax increases--that will not have any significant impact on our fiscal situation even if they are successful... but which most definitely could cause a dangerous impasse on the debt ceiling debate. Thanks, Obama, You Just Made it Harder As I mentioned above, I joked last week about Obama's entrance into the debate guaranteeing a debt crisis. I shouldn't have joked. It might not yet be guaranteed, but Obama made it more likely with his press conference yesterday. Once again the country awaited some useful input from the president. The country hoped for some leadership and enlightenment from this supposedly brilliant man to broker a difficult bipartisan compromise. Instead, the president helped the Democrats dig in on their position. Republicans asked Obama to get involved to help address the problem of spending and his participation has now made this an overt battle over tax increases. Once again, Obama has made a solution even less likely. Not only has he increased uncertainty over the debt ceiling, he has increased uncertainty for job creators trying to determine what their future costs will be and decide whether it makes sense to hire people. Without a tax policy they can count on, job creators will be less likely to hire people. So I once again must ask whether Obama wants this crisis? I asked this question back in April when he invited Rep. Paul Ryan to his budget speech only to rip him apart. And once again he has inserted himself into a partisan disagreement and only increased the partisanship with class warfare. Lines have been drawn in the sand. Republicans want spending cuts. Democrats want tax increases. Republicans can't budge on increasing taxes without killing their electoral prospects and Democrats and Obama can't fail to increase taxes without killing theirs. This has the potential to be an epic disagreement. Both sides disagree on the economic merits of the decision and both sides are politically compelled not to compromise. And the deadline is just over a month away. Everything is set for a historical political and economic confrontation that may lead to a debt crisis. And, thanks again to President Obama, we've moved further away from a solution. Go to the article list |